How does Aaron Judge's playoff performance compare to his regular-season numbers?

Over the course of his career, Judge's OPS has been 250 points lower in the postseason than in the regular season. This trend has continued in the 2025 playoffs, where he has posted a 1.024 OPS but with just one extra-base hit.

What is the key to the Yankees' success in the 2025 playoffs?

The key to the Yankees' success in the 2025 playoffs will be Aaron Judge's ability to rediscover his power stroke. The team's offense relies heavily on the two-time American League MVP, and his ability to punish mistakes over the middle of the plate will be crucial in determining whether the Yankees can overcome their current deficit against the Toronto Blue Jays.

Home / Sports / Yankees Slugger Aaron Judge Battles Playoff Power Drought

Yankees Slugger Aaron Judge Battles Playoff Power Drought

Q: Why is Aaron Judge struggling in the 2025 MLB playoffs?

Aaron Judge, the Yankees' star slugger, is struggling to find his power stroke in the 2025 MLB playoffs. Pitchers have been targeting him with a game plan of throwing hard stuff on the inside part of the plate, followed by softer offerings on the corners, which has proven effective in limiting his production.

8 Oct, 2025

•

Summary

Aaron Judge's OPS 250 points lower in playoffs than regular season
Pitchers targeting Judge with hard stuff inside, soft stuff away
Judge not taking advantage of middle-middle pitches in playoffs

Yankees Slugger Aaron Judge Battles Playoff Power Drought

As the 2025 MLB playoffs reach a critical juncture, the New York Yankees are facing elimination, and their star slugger Aaron Judge is at the center of their struggles. Over the course of his career, Judge has consistently underperformed in the postseason compared to his stellar regular-season numbers, with his OPS dropping by 250 points.

This year's playoffs have been no different, as Judge has posted a 1.024 OPS through his first five games, but with just one extra-base hit. Pitchers have been targeting him with a game plan of throwing hard stuff on the inside part of the plate, followed by softer offerings on the corners. This strategy has proven effective, as Judge has struggled to cover the entire strike zone against quality pitching.