Home / Sports / Judge's Return: Who Stays, Who Goes for Yankees?
Judge's Return: Who Stays, Who Goes for Yankees?
4 Sep
Summary
- Spencer Jones is too valuable to be removed from the roster.
- Giancarlo Stanton's contract complicates any potential retirement.
- Player health will determine if Nolan McLean or Cam Schlittler has a better career.

With Aaron Judge's return imminent, the Yankees are navigating a roster crunch. Despite the complication, Spencer Jones is deemed too valuable, particularly for his power threat, to be removed from the postseason roster. This suggests an infielder, possibly Amed Rosario, could be the one to make way, with versatile players like Jose Caballero or Luis Garcia Jr. offering options.
The future of Giancarlo Stanton remains a question mark. His substantial contract, which includes $25 million for next year and a buyout option for 2028, complicates retirement scenarios. His decision is expected to be the primary factor, with the Yankees potentially willing to offer him a role as a designated hitter or bench bat if he wishes to continue playing, despite recent leg issues.
Looking at emerging talent, the career paths of Nolan McLean and Cam Schlittler are largely dependent on their health. Both are highly talented, but Schlittler has shown better performance thus far and excels in high-pressure games. McLean's natural abilities are significant, and their ultimate success will likely be determined by which player remains healthiest.