Yankees Eye Reunion With Reliever Luke Weaver

The New York Yankees have expressed genuine interest in re-signing relief pitcher Luke Weaver, a move that would see him potentially return to the team. Weaver, who became a less trusted option by the end of the 2025 season, is considering his free-agent choices after about 10 teams inquired about him. His performance in 2025 saw an increase in ERA, partly due to a late-season hamstring strain and mechanical issues stemming from pitch tipping.

Despite a challenging second half of 2025, Weaver's underlying metrics, such as his chase and whiff rates, remain impressive. These underlying numbers are often prioritized by teams over surface-level statistics. Weaver demonstrated an ability to attack hitters in the zone, a quality the Yankees' bullpen struggled with in the past. His willingness to accept any high-leverage role, including closing or as a fireman, makes him an attractive target for the Yankees' current bullpen needs.

However, a reunion faces hurdles. The Yankees have a recent track record of avoiding multiyear contracts for premium free-agent relievers, a commitment Weaver is reportedly seeking. While Weaver's previous success and impressive metrics suggest he could be a valuable addition, the club's recent free-agent signing history indicates he may pursue opportunities elsewhere for the 2026 season.