Home / Sports / Vikings QB Debate: Mac Jones or J.J. McCarthy?
Vikings QB Debate: Mac Jones or J.J. McCarthy?
3 Dec, 2025
Summary
- Analyst suggests Mac Jones to compete for Vikings QB role.
- J.J. McCarthy has struggled with inconsistency and injuries.
- Vikings face Commanders in a crucial Week 14 matchup.
The Minnesota Vikings are facing significant questions at the quarterback position as their playoff hopes dwindle. Analyst Colin Cowherd has controversially suggested that the team should pursue Mac Jones from the San Francisco 49ers to challenge J.J. McCarthy for the starting role in 2026, citing McCarthy's struggles with health and efficiency.
Cowherd believes that acquiring Jones, who has shown promise as a backup for the 49ers, would be a strategic move to leverage the Vikings' talented offensive players like Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison. This potential move comes as McCarthy has been sidelined due to injury, with his performance metrics showing a higher number of interceptions than touchdowns this season.
Meanwhile, the Vikings, holding a 4-8 record, are preparing for a critical Week 14 game against the Washington Commanders, who have also been on a losing streak. McCarthy is expected to return as the starting quarterback for this matchup, underscoring the immediate need for stability as the season draws to a close.
