Sharks' Finals Collapse: Blame Game Begins

The Cronulla Sharks are facing an alarming late-season fade, with fears of a repeat of past finals collapses resurfacing. After being strong contenders for the minor premiership just weeks ago, the team has suffered shock losses to lower-ranked opponents, including the Dragons and Raiders, and an unconvincing win against the Titans. This poor run has dashed their top-four aspirations, settling them into fifth place for the finals.

Coach Craig Fitzgibbon's frustration was evident during their recent loss to the Eels, sparking debate among rugby league commentators about the team's mentality. Braith Anasta and Gorden Tallis suggested a possible psychological easing off from the team, while Dean Ritchie directly questioned if the Sharks are "choking" again.

The injury to five-eighth Braydon Trindall, who acts as the team's primary organizer, has been identified as a critical blow. His absence has highlighted the team's reliance on him and amplified concerns about their chances without him. Brent Read noted that winning a premiership from outside the top four is highly unlikely.

Furthermore, Nicho Hynes, the team's million-dollar playmaker, has faced scrutiny for his recent performances, particularly against the Eels. Experts like Anasta and Ritchie have called for more from Hynes, stating his form has been substandard during this crucial period, especially with Trindall out.

Since Craig Fitzgibbon took over in 2022, the Sharks have struggled in the finals, winning only three of their twelve matches. Their recent finals record includes two preliminary final losses. To succeed this year, a key spine player needs to step up in high-pressure games, a characteristic currently lacking.

The Sharks have been notably inactive in the player market recently, with no new signings from other clubs in the past 18 months. However, they face significant player departures in 2027, including Sione Katoa, Siosifa Talakai, and Jesse Ramien. If they fail to win the premiership this season, the club may face a rebuild, as their premiership window appears to be closing.