Saints' Kicker Woes: Carlson's Struggles Reignite Smyth Debate

The New Orleans Saints face a critical juncture with their kicking game as veteran Daniel Carlson struggles early in the 2026 season. Despite being projected to have Charlie Smyth for the 2026 season, the Saints cut Smyth in the preseason to opt for Carlson.

Carlson's performance through Week 5 has been inconsistent, marked by missed extra points and field goals, including attempts beyond 50 yards. Notably, he has already missed two extra points, a significant drop from his 95.5% success rate last season. His field goal percentage is also down to 71.4% this year compared to 81.5% in 2025.

This situation has brought Charlie Smyth back into focus. Smyth, originally from Northern Ireland, is currently a free agent. He played six games for the Saints in the 2025 season, converting 12 of 16 field goals, including four from 50-plus yards, and was perfect on extra points.

The Saints' decision to prioritize Carlson's experience over Smyth's upside is now under scrutiny as the team navigates a difficult 1-4 start. Head coach Kellen Moore has indicated no immediate plans to cut Carlson, but continued misses may force the team's hand.