Home / Sports / Orioles Draft Bust? Rutschman Outshone by Witt, Others
Orioles Draft Bust? Rutschman Outshone by Witt, Others
15 Jul
Summary
- Rutschman's stats trail key players like Bobby Witt Jr. from the 2019 draft.
- He ranks fifth in OPS among his draft peers, with lower total bases.
- Samuel Basallo is presented as the Orioles' potential next great catcher.

Adley Rutschman, the first overall draft selection by Orioles general manager Mike Elias in 2019, is underperforming compared to other players taken in that round. Notably, Bobby Witt Jr. has demonstrated superior performance across various metrics.
Statistical comparisons reveal Rutschman ranks fifth in OPS among his draft peers, including Witt Jr., Andrew Vaughn, Riley Greene, Corbin Carroll, Shea Langeliers, and CJ Abrams. He also trails them in crucial statistics like home runs and total bases, with lower win-probability added.
Further analysis indicates Rutschman's offensive numbers are not significantly surpassing those of Matt Wieters, another catcher drafted by the Orioles, despite Wieters' greater workload behind the plate. Wieters' power numbers and game-caught statistics are comparable or better.
The article suggests that Samuel Basallo, currently on the Orioles' roster, represents the franchise's true future at catcher. His performance at a young age is highlighted as historically significant, raising questions about Rutschman blocking his development.