Home / Sports / OBJ's Giants Return: A Last Hurrah?
OBJ's Giants Return: A Last Hurrah?
5 Jun
Summary
- Odell Beckham Jr. returns to the Giants after a four-year absence.
- He faces questions about his current ability due to age and injuries.
- The article examines past New York athletes' second acts.
Odell Beckham Jr. has returned to the New York Giants, four years after his initial departure. This move has generated considerable enthusiasm from the fanbase, recalling his impactful seasons with the team, including multiple 1,000-yard receiving seasons and memorable touchdown plays.
Despite the nostalgic appeal, Beckham is now 33 and has sustained two significant ACL tears in his left knee. The article examines whether he still possesses the capability to make the 53-man roster and contribute meaningfully.
The situation mirrors other instances of New York professional athletes returning for a "last hurrah," sometimes to their original clubs and occasionally to different New York teams. The article explores these historical precedents.
Notable former Giants include running back Brandon Jacobs, who had a second stint with the team after playing for San Francisco, and wide receiver Mario Manningham, who returned after a productive season with the 49ers but was sidelined by injury. Victor Cruz, another Giants receiver, also had a comeback attempt after a severe injury, but his speed had diminished by his return.
Other New York teams have also seen similar returns. Cornerback Darrelle Revis had a successful second chapter with the Jets, earning Pro Bowl selections. In baseball, Willie Mays returned to New York to finish his career with the Mets, though his production declined. Pitcher Andy Pettitte returned to the Yankees while still effective, playing a key role in their championship run.
Baseball also saw Rickey Henderson, who played for the Yankees and later the Mets, achieving success in his second stint with the latter. Basketball featured Mark Jackson returning to the Knicks, and Jason Kidd joining the Knicks after championship success elsewhere. Hockey legend Mark Messier returned to the Rangers for a second tour of duty, later retiring after a few seasons.
The parallels with these athletes raise questions about Beckham's potential impact. While it's possible for wide receivers in their 30s to remain productive, as evidenced by 2025 receiving leaders, the extent of Beckham's remaining capabilities at age 33 remains uncertain.
