What are some of the most regretted NHL trades by fans?

Fans often regret trades involving star players like Jack Eichel, Matthew Tkachuk, and Shea Theodore, where the team that traded them did not achieve desired success.

Which NHL teams have the most controversial trade history?

Teams like the Buffalo Sabres (Jack Eichel trade) and the Calgary Flames (Matthew Tkachuk trade) are frequently mentioned in discussions of controversial trades.

How do NHL expansion drafts impact fan-voted trade regrets?

Expansion drafts, like the one involving the Seattle Kraken, can lead to fan regret if a team trades away a valuable player to protect others or to avoid taking an undesirable player.

Home / Sports / NHL's Biggest Trade Regrets Revealed

NHL's Biggest Trade Regrets Revealed

22 Nov

•

Summary

Fans identify NHL trades they most regret.
Key players like Jack Eichel and Matthew Tkachuk feature prominently.
Decisions from 2002 to 2025 showcase historical trade impact.

Across the National Hockey League, fan bases are vocalizing their deepest trade regrets, looking back at decisions that continue to sting. From the early 2000s to recent years, specific transactions stand out as particularly painful, often involving star players and significant draft capital.

Fan opinions highlight moments where teams seemingly sacrificed future success for short-term gains or made decisions under pressure. Trades involving prominent figures like Jack Eichel, Matthew Tkachuk, and Shea Theodore are frequently cited, illustrating how player movement can alter a franchise's trajectory for years to come.

These retrospective analyses underscore the lasting impact of trade deadline dealings and expansion draft choices, offering a compelling look at the moments that hockey fans wish they could revisit and revise.

Disclaimer: This story has been auto-aggregated and auto-summarised by a computer program. This story has not been edited or created by the Feedzop team.