Which NHL teams are unexpectedly struggling in the 2025-26 season?

Teams like the Florida Panthers, Winnipeg Jets, and Toronto Maple Leafs, who had high playoff expectations, are currently underperforming and facing uncertain postseason futures.

How are injuries affecting NHL teams' playoff chances?

Significant injuries to star players, such as Matthew Tkachuk and Aleksander Barkov for the Panthers and Connor Hellebuyck for the Jets, are drastically reducing their playoff odds.

What does 'nemesis' mean in the context of NHL playoff races?

In this context, a 'nemesis' team is another team whose playoff fate is inversely correlated; if the nemesis makes the playoffs, the team's own chances decrease significantly.

Home / Sports / NHL Slump: Defending Champs Face Playoff Ouster

NHL Slump: Defending Champs Face Playoff Ouster

16 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

Injuries plague defending champs, impacting production.
Several teams with high preseason playoff odds struggle.
Key players' injuries and team performance affect playoff chances.

NHL Slump: Defending Champs Face Playoff Ouster

As the NHL season nears its traditional mid-December marker, several teams that entered with high playoff aspirations are now finding themselves on the wrong side of the postseason bubble. The two-time defending champions, for instance, are battling significant injuries to key players, drastically reducing their projected playoff chances.

Other teams, including Winnipeg and Toronto, are experiencing similar downturns. Winnipeg's struggles are exacerbated by their MVP goaltender's injury and offensive decline, while Toronto faces defensive lapses despite scoring improvements. These teams are now in direct competition with others for limited playoff berths.

This mid-season analysis highlights the unpredictability of the NHL, where early-season trends are becoming harder to dismiss. The fate of these underperforming teams is increasingly tied to their rivals, creating intense "nemesis" matchups as they vie for a chance to extend their seasons into the playoffs.