Home / Sports / Giants Lose Bailey, Then Lose Big in Ugly Defeat
Giants Lose Bailey, Then Lose Big in Ugly Defeat
10 May
Summary
- Giants traded catcher Patrick Bailey to the Cleveland Guardians.
- The team suffered a particularly unsightly 13-3 loss to the Pirates.
- Bryce Eldridge hit his first major league home run in the game.

The San Francisco Giants traded catcher Patrick Bailey to the Cleveland Guardians on Saturday morning. This transaction preceded a particularly rough 13-3 loss to the Pittsburgh Pirates, which many observers deemed one of the team's most unsightly games of the season. The Giants' lineup struggled, making early-count outs, and their defense was plagued by errors. Ryan Walker, a former closer, faced fan disapproval for his pitching.
Amidst the team's struggles, 21-year-old prospect Bryce Eldridge hit his first major league home run. The solo shot in the fifth inning against Braxton Ashcraft landed in McCovey Cove, offering a momentary spark. Eldridge described the experience as surreal, recalling a "blackout" moment after rounding third base. Manager Tony Vitello praised Eldridge's impressive swing for its contact and ability to stay fair on an inside fastball.
Manager Tony Vitello also noted the Giants' extended dry spell without a walk, spanning 130 plate appearances, a streak not seen since September 1952. This lack of patience at the plate was evident, with few three-ball counts. The game's optics were further criticized, with a pitching change confusion involving second base umpire Scott Barry and a bewildered bullpen.
These issues have led to fan dissatisfaction, with audible boos heard from the stands. President Buster Posey's emphasis on "optics" and clean receiving, contrasted with the team's current presentation, was highlighted. The article suggests the team's current form, especially after trading Bailey, appears "damaged beyond repair" and lacks the professionalism Posey values.