Why is the Giants' defense performing poorly despite having talented players?

The Giants' defense has struggled due to issues with execution, coaching, and overall personnel assembly, leading to a decline in rankings despite the presence of talented individuals.

What has Joe Schoen said about the Giants' defensive struggles?

General Manager Joe Schoen acknowledged that he needs to improve how he assembles the team's personnel and pointed to coaching and player execution as areas needing betterment.

Which key defensive players are under contract for the Giants?

Key defensive players like Dexter Lawrence, Brian Burns, and Jevon Holland are under contract with the Giants through the 2026 and 2027 seasons.

Home / Sports / Giants Defense: Talent vs. Poor Results?

Giants Defense: Talent vs. Poor Results?

11 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

Defense worsened from 21st to 30th in points allowed.
GM Schoen cites execution and coaching for defensive struggles.
Key defensive players under contract through 2027.

Giants Defense: Talent vs. Poor Results?

The New York Giants' defense, despite featuring notable talent, has experienced a significant decline this season, dropping to 30th in points allowed. General Manager Joe Schoen has publicly expressed his inability to explain the unit's struggles, admitting fault in personnel assembly and execution. He indicated that coaching will be a focus for the next hire, aiming to get players working cohesively.

The defensive line boasts Dexter Lawrence, but lacks significant depth, while the edge rusher group has potential with Brian Burns and Kayvon Thibodeaux, though performance has varied. The linebacker corps requires substantial upgrades, as the current unit is not meeting expectations. Significant investments in the secondary have also yielded underwhelming returns, with players like Adoree' Jackson and Jevon Holland underperforming relative to their contracts.

Overall, the Giants' defensive struggles are a complex issue involving talent evaluation, coaching, and player execution. With a 2-11 record, the team faces a long road to improvement, necessitating strategic personnel decisions and potentially premium investments to address the numerous holes on the roster, particularly in the defensive trenches and secondary.