Why did Shannon Sharpe criticize the Indianapolis Colts' QB decision?

Shannon Sharpe believes the Colts have lost faith in Anthony Richardson and that starting Philip Rivers signals this.

What past incident did Shannon Sharpe mention regarding Anthony Richardson?

Sharpe referenced Anthony Richardson's 'tap out' moment from last season as an example of questionable mental toughness.

Did the Colts make a mistake in developing Anthony Richardson, according to the article?

Shannon Sharpe suggested the Colts may have rushed Anthony Richardson's development, potentially doing him a disservice.

Home / Sports / Shannon Sharpe Blasts Colts: 'They're So Over Him'

Shannon Sharpe Blasts Colts: 'They're So Over Him'

17 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

Shannon Sharpe criticizes Colts' QB decision as loss of faith in Richardson.
Sharpe cites Richardson's 'tap out' incident as a key reason for doubt.
Colts organization is questioned for potentially rushing Richardson's development.

Shannon Sharpe Blasts Colts: 'They're So Over Him'

Hall of Fame tight end Shannon Sharpe has sharply criticized the Indianapolis Colts' decision to start 44-year-old Philip Rivers over Anthony Richardson. Sharpe suggested this move indicates the franchise has already lost faith in its former top-five draft pick, framing it as more than a temporary solution. The debate intensified after Daniel Jones' season-ending injury, with many expecting Richardson to get another chance.

Sharpe voiced his strong opinion on the Nightcap podcast, stating, "I think they're so over him." He pointed to Richardson's "tap out" incident last season, where the quarterback briefly exited a game due to fatigue, as a critical factor eroding trust. Sharpe emphasized that this mindset deviates from the expected toughness required of quarterbacks.