Home / Sports / Colts Kicker Battle Heats Up: Who Will Kick?
Colts Kicker Battle Heats Up: Who Will Kick?
1 Aug
Summary
- Kicker competition features Spencer Shrader and Blake Grupe.
- Grupe led in the first observed field goal period.
- Shrader was nearly automatic before a 2025 season injury.
The Indianapolis Colts are engaged in a fierce competition for their starting kicker position between Spencer Shrader and Blake Grupe. This battle is crucial for the team's stability, especially after experiencing kicking inconsistencies following Shrader's season-ending injury in 2025.
During the initial Family Day practice, Grupe established an early lead by successfully converting all six of his field goal attempts, ranging from 32 to 55 yards. Shrader, who had an elite performance in 2025 before his injury, managed five out of six successful kicks.
Special teams coordinator Brian Mason emphasized the team's commitment to ensuring a balanced competition, providing both kickers with an equal number of opportunities. Shrader, who tore his ACL and MCL, had made 13 of 14 field goals and all 14 extra points before his injury.
After Shrader's injury, the Colts utilized Michael Badgley and later Grupe. Grupe proved flawless in the final five games of the 2025 season, converting all 11 field goals and 10 extra points. This strong finish complicates the decision for the Colts, as Shrader acknowledges Grupe's proven NFL starting capability.
