Home / Sports / Cardinals' Catcher Conundrum: Who Will Make the Cut?
Cardinals' Catcher Conundrum: Who Will Make the Cut?
12 Nov
Summary
- Cardinals roster currently has four catchers, with top prospect not included.
- Leo Bernal impressed in September call-up, viewed as likely Opening Day catcher.
- Rainiel Rodriguez, a top prospect, is also being tested at first base and third.
The St. Louis Cardinals are evaluating a surplus of catching talent as they shape their roster for 2027 and beyond. The organization currently boasts four catchers on its 40-man roster, not including its top prospect. This depth necessitates difficult decisions regarding player retention and development.
Leo Bernal, a former top prospect, made a significant impression during his September call-up in 2026. He demonstrated strong offensive capabilities with an .807 OPS and exceptional defensive skills, earning praise from leadership. Bernal is widely considered the frontrunner to be the Cardinals' Opening Day catcher.
Other notable catchers include Jimmy Crooks and Iván Herrera, both highly regarded prospects whose major league performance in 2026 showed mixed results. Pedro Pagés is valued for his defensive prowess but faces an uncertain roster future due to offensive limitations.
Adding to the complexity is Rainiel Rodriguez, MLB Pipeline's No. 10 prospect and the top catcher on their list. Rodriguez has excelled at every level, posting a .999 OPS at Double-A Springfield in 2026. The Cardinals are exploring his versatility, having him play first base and even third base, with his bat showing potential to play at any position.
