Home / Sports / Canada's Goalie Puzzle: Who Will Marsch Pick?
Canada's Goalie Puzzle: Who Will Marsch Pick?
26 Mar
Summary
- Coach Jesse Marsch has not named Canada's starting World Cup goalkeeper.
- Both top contenders, St. Clair and Crépeau, are struggling in MLS.
- Marsch prefers not to rotate goalkeepers during the World Cup.
As the World Cup approaches, Canada's national soccer team faces a critical unanswered question: who will start in goal? Coach Jesse Marsch has not yet named a definitive starter between Dayne St. Clair, the reigning MLS Goalkeeper of the Year, and veteran Maxime Crépeau. This uncertainty persists despite the upcoming June 12 opener.
Both St. Clair and Crépeau have endured a challenging beginning to their 2026 MLS seasons. St. Clair currently has the fifth-worst save rate in the league at 55.6 percent, while Crépeau leads with the worst goals conceded per 90 minutes at 3.5. This lack of consistent club form adds pressure to their national team prospects.
Marsch has historically alternated starts between the two goalkeepers during international windows, aiming to evaluate their capabilities. However, he does not want to rotate keepers during the World Cup itself. The coaching staff sees potential in both, noting St. Clair's athleticism and Crépeau's leadership and big-game experience.
Recent international performances have shown mixed results for both keepers. While St. Clair faced fewer shots and conceded no goals in late 2025 matches against higher-ranked opponents, Crépeau has demonstrated crucial saves in past high-stakes games, such as against Argentina in Copa América. The decision is expected soon, with St. Clair currently perceived to hold a slight edge.
