Bills Seek New Punt Returner: Who Will Step Up?

The Buffalo Bills are facing a critical offseason decision regarding their punt returner position. With a 2025 average of just 6.5 yards per return, ranking 29th in the NFL, the team is looking to upgrade from Khalil Shakir, who has held the role for two seasons. The Bills aim to find a player capable of generating explosive plays and avoid exposing their top wide receiver to unnecessary risks.

Several candidates are emerging for what promises to be a competitive training camp battle. Rookie Keon Coleman, who had limited punt return duties last season, is a possibility. Reserve wide receiver Mecole Hardman Jr. was brought in midseason but struggled with fumbles and injuries. Safety Jalon Kilgore also has some return experience, though limited. Undrafted free agent Desmond Reid stands out with an impressive 14.7 yards per return average over the past two seasons, including two touchdowns, making him a significant contender for the role.