Bengals Rookie Class C- Minus: First-Round Pick Falters

Cincinnati's 2025 rookie class received a C+ grade, ranking 25th overall in the NFL. A significant portion of the assessment stems from the performance of first-round edge rusher Shemar Stewart, who struggled in his debut season. Stewart recorded just one sack in eight games, hindered by a contract dispute and multiple injuries, a disappointing return on a high draft selection.

Despite the setback with Stewart, the Bengals found brighter spots in later draft picks. Dylan Fairchild emerged as a solid 15-game starter at left guard, contributing significantly to the offensive line. Linebackers Demetrius Knight Jr. and Barrett Carter, thrust into starting roles on defense, gained valuable experience despite early mistakes. They demonstrated growth and tied for second on the team with 106 tackles, showing potential for their sophomore seasons.