Home / Sports / Bayern Denied Penalty by Obscure Handball Rule
Bayern Denied Penalty by Obscure Handball Rule
6 May
Summary
- Bayern players and fans disputed a handball call against Joao Neves.
- The referee and VAR did not award a penalty for the incident.
- A little-known exemption in handball law likely caused the decision.

During a crucial Champions League semi-final second leg, Bayern Munich players and fans at the Allianz Arena were bewildered when a penalty was not awarded for a handball by Paris St-Germain's Joao Neves. Trailing 1-0 on the night and 6-4 on aggregate, Bayern's appeals were dismissed by referee Joao Pedro Silva Pinheiro.
The incident occurred when Vitinha's clearance struck his teammate Neves' arm inside the penalty area. Neither the on-field officials nor the VAR intervened, prompting widespread confusion. According to football law expert Dale Johnson, the decision was likely based on a less common exemption within the handball regulations.
This exemption states that a handball offense is not committed if the ball unintentionally strikes a player's hand or arm after being played by a teammate. Johnson explained that penalties are not typically awarded in such scenarios, even if the arm is in a position away from the body, unless the handball is deliberate or leads to an immediate goal.