Why did analyst Jason McIntyre compare Caleb Williams to Johnny Manziel?

Analyst Jason McIntyre compared rising Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams to former NFL bust Johnny Manziel, suggesting they share similar issues with pocket presence. However, experts argue this comparison is misguided, as Williams is known for his dedication to football, unlike Manziel's off-field troubles that cut his career short.

How did Caleb Williams respond to the Johnny Manziel comparison?

The article does not mention Caleb Williams directly responding to the controversial comparison made by analyst Jason McIntyre. The focus is on the expert criticism of the comparison, which they argue misses the mark and fails to recognize Williams' dedication to his football career.

What is the main reason the Johnny Manziel comparison to Caleb Williams is considered inaccurate?

The key difference between Caleb Williams and Johnny Manziel is that Manziel's NFL career was cut short primarily due to his off-field issues and demons, while Williams is described as being "as locked in on his football career as you'd expect from a franchise quarterback." Experts argue this fundamental difference makes the comparison between the two players inaccurate and misleading.

Home / Sports / Analyst's Shocking Comparison: Caleb Williams Likened to Bust QB Johnny Manziel

Analyst's Shocking Comparison: Caleb Williams Likened to Bust QB Johnny Manziel

9 Aug

•

Summary

Analyst Jason McIntyre compares Caleb Williams to failed NFL QB Johnny Manziel
Manziel's career was cut short due to off-field issues, unlike Williams' focus
Analysts know controversial takes on Caleb Williams will go viral

Analyst's Shocking Comparison: Caleb Williams Likened to Bust QB Johnny Manziel

On August 9th, 2025, a controversial comparison emerged regarding rising Chicago Bears quarterback Caleb Williams. While filling in for Colin Cowherd on 'The Herd,' analyst Jason McIntyre drew a parallel between Williams and former NFL bust Johnny Manziel.

McIntyre's suggestion that Williams shares the same pocket presence—or lack thereof—that ultimately doomed Manziel's career has been widely criticized. Manziel, a 2014 first-round pick of the Cleveland Browns, was out of the league by 2016 due to his off-field issues, a fate that experts say is unlikely to befall the focused Williams.

The real takeaway from McIntyre's bizarre comparison is that analysts are aware that any hot take on Caleb Williams will garner significant attention. By linking the promising young quarterback to the failed Manziel, McIntyre has not only secured a seat at the viral table, but has positioned himself as the head of it.

Disclaimer: This story has been auto-aggregated and auto-summarised by a computer program. This story has not been edited or created by the Feedzop team.