NYC Bagpipers: Loud Neighbors, Loud Instruments

Bagpipers in New York City often turn to unconventional outdoor locations for practice, facing noise complaints and even police attention. Cristopher Rodriguez, like many others, has experienced confrontations for playing his loud instrument in public parks, leading him to seek out spaces like cemeteries and overlooks near highways. This practice of al fresco musicianship is common, with jazz saxophonist Sonny Rollins famously practicing on the Williamsburg Bridge.

Finding a suitable practice spot is a persistent challenge for these musicians. James Felder moved from the waterfront to Central Park, enduring smells of trash and horse manure. John Henderson practices near a hardware store and in Friends Cemetery, where other recreational activities occur. The bagpipe's 'skirl' can reach 100 decibels, comparable to a motorcycle, making quiet practice difficult.

Despite the difficulties, bagpipers remain vital to New York's cultural fabric, performing at parades, weddings, and unique events, sometimes for surprising sums. John McCarthy played for 15 minutes every Monday morning for years outside an apartment building on Central Park South for an unknown patron. While most avoid practicing at home, John Macpherson does so cautiously, acknowledging a neighbor once spat on his door.

These musicians, often holding day jobs, are devoted to their craft, seeking secluded areas like cemeteries, underpasses, or riverside parks. Joe Korber notes that violinists don't face similar struggles. While many dream of quieter suburban spaces, New York City continues to be a hub for bagpiping, a testament to the musicians' dedication to both their instruments and the city.