Why did the baker refuse to make her sister's wedding cake for free?

The baker declined because the cake would cost over $500 in ingredients and require three full days of work, and she has had stressful, unpaid experiences with free cakes before.

What was the bride's reaction to the baker's offer?

The bride 'flipped out' when her sister offered a discounted rate instead of a free cake, calling her sister greedy.

What did Redditors say about the free wedding cake situation?

Most Redditors on the 'Am I the Jerk' forum supported the baker, stating her time, expertise, and labor should be valued and compensated.

Home / Lifestyle / Baker Refuses Free Wedding Cake for Sister

Baker Refuses Free Wedding Cake for Sister

21 Nov

•

Summary

Baker declined sister's request for a free wedding cake.
The cake would cost over $500 in ingredients alone.
Redditors largely supported the baker's decision.

Baker Refuses Free Wedding Cake for Sister

A 30-year-old professional baker has sparked a family dispute by refusing to provide a free wedding cake for her 27-year-old sister. The bride and their family believe the baker should offer the cake as a gift, but the baker explained the significant cost of ingredients, exceeding $500, and the three full days of work required.

When the bride insisted on a free cake, citing financial inability, the baker offered a discounted rate to cover material and labor costs for her assistant. This offer was met with anger, with the bride accusing her sister of being greedy. The baker, having previously made cakes for loved ones without charge, stated she learned her lesson from past stressful, unpaid experiences.

Online, the consensus on Reddit's "Am I the Jerk" forum largely supported the baker. Many users commented that family should help each other by contributing to the cost, rather than expecting free labor. They stressed that the baker's time, expertise, and labor are valuable and should be compensated, especially for an elaborate event like a wedding.