What was the New York top court ruling on the Seneca Falls landfill?

The court ruled that Seneca Meadows Inc. has the right to challenge the town's landfill shutdown law, but the law itself remains in effect.

Will the Seneca Falls landfill close as planned?

The law to close the landfill remains in effect, but its future is subject to ongoing legal review and DEC permit decisions.

What is the DEC reviewing regarding Seneca Meadows?

The DEC is reviewing Seneca Meadows' applications for a new permit and a 47-acre expansion for the landfill.

Home / Environment / Seneca Falls Landfill Law Stands Firm Despite Court Ruling

Seneca Falls Landfill Law Stands Firm Despite Court Ruling

21 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

New York's top court allows challenge to Seneca Falls' landfill shutdown law.
The core legal fight now returns to the Appellate Division for review.
DEC is reviewing Seneca Meadows' requests for permit and expansion.

Seneca Falls Landfill Law Stands Firm Despite Court Ruling

A recent decision by New York's highest court has affirmed that Seneca Falls' local law to shut down its landfill remains in effect. The Court of Appeals ruled that Seneca Meadows Inc. possesses the right to legally contest Local Law 3. However, CCSC President Glen Silver characterized this ruling as a procedural step rather than a fundamental blow to the law's integrity.

The central legal conflict is now set to return to the Appellate Division. This court will undertake a detailed review of both the environmental implications and the stipulated timelines associated with the landfill's closure. The existing law, intended to cease landfill operations, continues to be legally binding and operative.

Concurrently, the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation is evaluating Seneca Meadows' submitted requests. These include applications for a new operating permit and a substantial 47-acre expansion, proposals that could potentially extend the landfill's operational lifespan significantly, possibly until the year 2040.