Citrus Grove Fight: Golf Course or Preserve?

In Naples, Florida, the future of the South Naples Citrus Grove, a decades-old business, is at the center of a heated local debate. A developer, SWJR Naples LLC, is seeking to rezone the 169 acres of agricultural land, currently occupied by the grove, which is within the state's "Florida Forever" conservation boundary.

Initially, the developer proposed rezoning for up to 423 homes, including income-restricted housing. This plan faced strong opposition from residents citing concerns about increased development and potential impacts on wildlife, including endangered Florida panthers, and water management. Environmental policy experts also voiced concerns.

The developer has since shifted its proposal to an 18-hole private golf course with a clubhouse and cabins. However, this new plan has also met significant resistance, with locals fearing it's a precursor to residential development and will increase traffic and noise.

Collier County is currently weighing its options. An advisory committee will make a recommendation on August 6, with the county commissioners set to make a final decision on the golf course proposal in September 2026. Additionally, an appraisal is underway to determine if the property could be acquired using Conservation Collier funds for preservation.

Residents like Gwen Ransone and Susan Scalf are actively opposing the development, emphasizing their desire for peace and quiet and expressing distrust of the developer's intentions. The ultimate decision rests with the landowner and the county commissioners' vote.