HOA Sued Over Goose Culling Plan

Homeowners in the Heritage Plantation subdivision have filed a lawsuit in Madison County Circuit Court to prevent their Homeowners Association (HOA) from proceeding with a planned culling of the community's Canada geese population. A hearing regarding a temporary restraining order is scheduled for Wednesday, June 26, 2026. The plaintiffs, represented by attorney Angie Ingram, argue that the HOA misrepresented a September 2025 USDA letter, which they claim outlined options rather than mandating euthanasia.

The lawsuit further alleges that resident surveys failed to clarify that 'removal' meant the geese would be killed. It also states the HOA has not fully implemented environmental vendor recommendations for water treatment before resorting to lethal measures. Attorney Ingram also raised concerns about potential violations of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, citing the placement of a corn feeder near community lakes, which could constitute illegal baiting.

Ingram expressed disappointment that legal action was necessary, especially after a neighboring HOA, Edgewater, recently reversed a similar culling plan due to public pressure and media attention. She noted that Heritage Plantation's HOA had not yet formally responded to the lawsuit, citing the need to consult their attorney.