Home / Crime and Justice / Teen Accused of Shooting Victim Four Times in Argument
Teen Accused of Shooting Victim Four Times in Argument
29 Jul
Summary
- A 17-year-old is charged with attempted murder for firing a gun.
- The shooting occurred during an argument between two adults.
- A defense attorney noted the context of the relationship is crucial.

A 17-year-old female, Carrie Shay Holmes, has been arrested and charged with attempted murder by the Nassau County Sheriff's Office. The incident occurred Monday afternoon in Callahan, off Gwen Avenue, where Holmes allegedly fired a gun four times.
The shooting reportedly took place during a volatile argument between two adults. Reports indicate that one individual escalated the conflict with aggressive language. The victim was allegedly holding the gun during the dispute before placing it down.
According to the arrest report, Holmes then retrieved the gun and fired it at the suspect. A criminal defense attorney, not involved in the case, stated that the circumstances do not appear unprovoked. She stressed the importance of understanding the relationship history and any past violence for legal context.
Authorities are continuing to investigate the incident and are working to determine when Holmes will appear in court. Further details regarding past domestic violence incidents are also being sought.