Home / Crime and Justice / CPS Knew of Expert Probe During Letby Case

CPS Knew of Expert Probe During Letby Case

Summary

  • Prosecution knew expert witness faced GMC probe before second court appearance.
  • Expert testified two babies were poisoned with insulin in Letby trial.
  • Expert relinquished registration before GMC investigation concluded.

Authorities were aware that an expert witness whose testimony was critical in the Lucy Letby trial was under investigation for his professional conduct. Professor Peter Hindmarsh had testified that he believed two infants Letby was accused of attempting to murder had been poisoned with insulin. This testimony was given while Hindmarsh was facing a referral to the General Medical Council (GMC).

The Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) knew of the GMC investigation before Professor Hindmarsh made his second court appearance. He had testified in February 2023 at Manchester Crown Court, asserting that insulin poisoning was the only logical explanation for a baby's abnormal blood readings. The court heard that this baby's insulin levels were exceptionally high.

According to CPS guidance from 2022, information casting doubt on an expert's credibility requires consideration of disclosure implications, as it could render past convictions unsafe. The CPS stated that regulatory investigations are separate from criminal proceedings and do not automatically affect evidence admissibility. Hindmarsh voluntarily relinquished his GMC registration in November 2024, prior to the investigation's conclusion.

The defense team was informed of the investigation but reportedly did not apply to present this information to the jury, as the CPS indicated they would oppose it due to the investigation not having reached a final conclusion. Reports suggest the CPS may not have been aware of a prior tribunal ruling that barred Hindmarsh from treating patients.

Disclaimer: This story has been auto-aggregated and auto-summarised by a computer program. This story has not been edited or created by the Feedzop team.

Read more news on

Property Code: 5571