Home / Crime and Justice / Maximum Sentence for Brutal Brother-in-Law Slaying
Maximum Sentence for Brutal Brother-in-Law Slaying
29 Jul
Summary
- John Singh received 25 years to life for fatally stabbing his brother-in-law.
- Singh claimed self-defense, but jurors rejected his claim.
- The judge cited Singh's lack of remorse and a calculated act.
On July 29, 2026, John Singh received a maximum sentence of 25 years to life for fatally stabbing his brother-in-law, Bernard Barua. The judge presiding over the case in Westchester cited the defendant's callous and calculated actions in imposing the severe penalty.
Singh, 55, had been living with Barua, 78, and his sister in their Yonkers apartment. He called 911 to report a stabbing, admitting he had also stabbed Barua. Police found Barua deceased in his bed.
During the trial, Singh maintained he acted in self-defense, alleging Barua attacked him with a knife. However, prosecutors successfully argued against this, highlighting a lack of evidence of a struggle in the location Singh described. The prosecution also pointed to a self-inflicted chest wound on Singh and his written statements blaming others, underscoring his lack of remorse.
Despite pleas for leniency from family members, including Singh's sister, the judge emphasized Barua's vulnerability and the betrayal of his compassion. The defense attorney requested a minimum sentence, but the judge found no basis for leniency, stating Barua deserved better than to be the victim of such a crime.
