Can AI be used to create fake evidence in domestic violence cases like in Melissa Sims' situation?

Yes, AI can be used to generate convincing fake texts or other digital evidence, which can be misused in legal proceedings, as seen in Melissa Sims' case.

What happened to nurse Melissa Sims in Florida?

Melissa Sims was twice arrested and jailed based on allegedly fabricated text messages created by her ex-boyfriend, leading to significant personal and financial hardship.

What is 'Melissa's Law' that the Florida nurse is advocating for?

'Melissa's Law' is proposed legislation aimed at strengthening protections for victims and preventing the misuse of AI and digital evidence in Florida's legal system.

Home / Crime and Justice / AI Fuels False Arrest: Nurse Jailed Over Fake Texts

AI Fuels False Arrest: Nurse Jailed Over Fake Texts

10 Jan

•

Summary

Nurse Melissa Sims was jailed twice based on fabricated text messages.
An ex-boyfriend allegedly used AI to create fake evidence against her.
She lost her job, nursing license, and suffered financial loss.

AI Fuels False Arrest: Nurse Jailed Over Fake Texts

An innocent Florida nurse, Melissa Sims, endured two harrowing jail experiences due to alleged AI-generated false evidence presented by her ex-boyfriend. Following a contentious breakup in November 2024, Sims reported her ex-boyfriend for alleged theft, only to be subsequently arrested herself on domestic violence charges. This initial arrest led to a night in jail and a restraining order.

Months later, Sims faced a second arrest for allegedly violating her bond, based on a text message prosecutors later conceded was unverified and unproven by cellphone records. This message, purportedly sent after a pickleball court encounter, falsely implicated Sims. She claims her ex-boyfriend even inflicted injuries on himself to support his false accusations.

As a consequence of these false accusations, Sims lost her part-time job, was unable to practice nursing, and was barred from her condo for 19 days, estimating financial losses exceeding $100,000. Although her charges were eventually dropped and she was acquitted in December 2025, Sims is now campaigning for "Melissa's Law" to prevent the misuse of AI evidence.