Deputy's Murder Conviction Upheld on Appeal

The state Supreme Court has affirmed the murder conviction of an Alameda County sheriff's deputy, Devin Williams, who was found guilty of killing his girlfriend and her husband in September 2022. Williams was sentenced to 50 years to life in prison for the fatal shootings. The victims' family received a $36 million settlement from the county.

Williams fatally shot Maria Tran, 42, and Benison Tran, 57, at their Dublin home after an argument. He had learned that Maria Tran was still married to Benison Tran, despite her initial claims of being divorced. He entered their home, shot Benison Tran as he attempted to call 911, and then shot Maria Tran.

During the trial, Williams' defense argued for a lesser charge of involuntary manslaughter, claiming he acted in the heat of passion. However, a jury convicted him of two counts of first-degree murder, indicating the killings were intentional and premeditated. His appeal focused on the admission of graphic crime scene photos, but the appellate court ruled they were necessary for the jury's understanding.

The case, People v. Williams, saw its final judicial review as the state Supreme Court unanimously denied the deputy's petition for review, upholding the previous appellate court's decision. Williams' lawyer declined to comment on the ruling.