Home / Crime and Justice / Stalker's Decade-Long Reign of Terror Ends for CSI: Miami Star
Stalker's Decade-Long Reign of Terror Ends for CSI: Miami Star
23 Oct
Summary
- Actress Eva LaRue received disturbing threats for 12 years
- Stalker impersonated "Freddie Krueger" to threaten rape and murder
- Suspect apprehended in 2022 and sentenced to 40 months in prison
In October 2025, a new documentary series titled "My Nightmare Stalker: The Eva LaRue Story" is set to premiere on Paramount+, shedding light on the harrowing 12-year ordeal faced by CSI: Miami actress Eva LaRue and her daughter Kaya Callahan.
The nightmare began in 2007 when LaRue, at the pinnacle of her acting career, received a disturbing note signed by "Freddie Krueger." Over the next several years, the stalker sent dozens more threatening letters, repeatedly vowing to rape and kill both LaRue and her daughter. The situation escalated in 2019 when the stalker called Kaya's high school, pretending to be her father and making chilling threats.
After years of exhaustive efforts by local and federal investigators, a suspect was finally apprehended in 2022. The 58-year-old Ohio man, James David Rogers, pleaded guilty to charges including mailing threatening communications and stalking. He was sentenced to 40 months in prison and released in 2024.
The upcoming documentary series delves into the psychological trauma experienced by LaRue and her daughter, as well as the FBI's hunt for the elusive stalker whose threats terrorized the family for over a decade.
