Home / Crime and Justice / Evidence Upheld: Coleman Murder Trial to Proceed
Evidence Upheld: Coleman Murder Trial to Proceed
14 Jul
Summary
- Judge ruled evidence sufficient for trial despite mental health claims.
- Coleman accused of killing Carl Johnson during argument at his home.
- This is the second time the case has been cleared to proceed to trial.
For the second time, a judge has determined there is enough evidence to move forward with a murder trial for Stewart Coleman. Coleman stands accused of killing Carl Johnson approximately one year ago in August. Prosecutors presented evidence, including a handgun recovered from the scene. Testimony revealed the fatal incident occurred after Johnson visited Coleman's Northwest Fresno home to view fishing gear, leading to an argument and subsequent shooting.
During court proceedings, prosecutors highlighted witness statements describing the victim's fear and Coleman's apparent possession of a handgun. The defense argued against proceeding, citing insufficient malice aforethought and raising concerns about Coleman's mental health, noting he suffers from schizophrenia. This is the second instance where the case has been cleared for trial, following an earlier dismissal and refiling.
Coleman is scheduled to appear in court again on July 28. Members of the victim's family were present in the courtroom during the proceedings.
