Home / Crime and Justice / Carer Wins £30K After Being Fired for Chatting

Carer Wins £30K After Being Fired for Chatting

Summary

  • Carer awarded £29,628 for unfair dismissal after discussing Christmas bonuses.
  • Tribunal found no evidence of instruction forbidding bonus discussions.
  • Dismissal for alleged misconduct was deemed flawed by the employment tribunal.
Carer Wins £30K After Being Fired for Chatting

Donna Williams, a carer who joined Copthorne Care Homes in August 2012, has successfully won an unfair dismissal case, securing £29,628. The dispute arose after the care home's ownership changed in 2022, leading to a shift from all staff receiving Christmas bonuses to a policy rewarding only those going 'above and beyond'.

In January 2024, Ms. Williams faced disciplinary action for discussing the Christmas bonus cuts with colleagues. She also received a written warning for alleged issues with vegetable preparation and for sitting in a conservatory while waiting to start her shift. The Bodmin Employment Tribunal noted the care home provided no evidence that staff had been instructed not to discuss bonuses prior to the disciplinary proceedings.

Further disciplinary matters occurred in March 2024, including allegations of negligence regarding service user care. Ms. Williams was issued a final written warning. After appealing and taking sick leave, she returned to work in June 2024 but was suspended again for discussing confidential information and allegedly 'bad mouthing' a colleague involved in the disciplinary process.

Her subsequent dismissal on June 27, 2024, was found to be flawed by the tribunal. The panel ruled the care home did not have a genuine belief that misconduct occurred and that the dismissal was not based on reasonable grounds. The tribunal upheld her claim of unfair dismissal, also awarding her £2,680 for unpaid notice pay and over £18,000 in losses.

Disclaimer: This story has been auto-aggregated and auto-summarised by a computer program. This story has not been edited or created by the Feedzop team.

Read more news on

Property Code: 5571