Home / Crime and Justice / Fake Citations: Attorneys Punished for AI Errors
Fake Citations: Attorneys Punished for AI Errors
17 Mar
Summary
- Attorneys sanctioned for submitting fake case citations.
- Court orders lawyers to pay $15,000 each and legal fees.
- Sanctions highlight concerns over AI 'hallucinations' in law.
A U.S. federal appeals court panel has sanctioned two attorneys, Van Irion and Russ Egli, for submitting an appeal with numerous fake case citations that misrepresented the law. The Cincinnati-based 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals stated that the attorneys "sullied the reputation of our bar" with their conduct.
The court identified more than two dozen fabricated citations and factual misrepresentations within the appeal, which pertained to an incident at a fireworks show in Athens, Tennessee. The attorneys were questioned by the court regarding their vetting process and potential use of generative AI but did not directly answer, instead challenging the court's order.
As a penalty, Irion and Egli must reimburse the city of Athens for its legal expenses and each pay $15,000 to the appeals court. The sanctions serve as a stark warning as courts increasingly grapple with AI-generated inaccuracies, emphasizing lawyers' duty to verify the integrity of all submitted documents.
