Family Secrets Unfold in New Documentary

Robert Greene's latest documentary, "Too Much Sugar," offers a compelling look at a working-class Missouri family, challenging notions of authorship and authenticity in nonfiction filmmaking. The film initially focuses on Ryan Hollinger, a self-styled patriarch whose perception of himself as the main character is gradually subverted by other family members.

As the documentary progresses, it becomes clear that the film is about more than just fatherhood. Various individuals within Ryan's orbit share their contrasting experiences, revealing themes of grief, trauma, healing, and liberation. The subjects are given the freedom to create their own short films, which are then integrated into the main narrative, creating a multifaceted and shape-shifting portrait of the family.

While Ryan is presented as a charismatic but challenging figure, his on-off partner of 18 years, Amanda, emerges as the most sympathetic and vital character. Her growing voice highlights Ryan's history of infidelity and neglect, offering a counter-narrative to his self-aggrandizing persona. The film also features contributions from Greene's students and his son, who composed the score.

"Too Much Sugar" ultimately becomes a communal effort, showcasing how collaboration and compromise can alter even the most dominant visions. The most impactful developments are unscripted, reflecting changes within Ryan's family structure that he cannot control, leading to a film that is both lively and humble.