Crash vs. Brokeback: The Oscars Scandal Remembered

The 2006 Academy Awards ceremony is still remembered for its most controversial moment: "Crash" unexpectedly winning Best Picture over the highly favored "Brokeback Mountain." This decision, 20 years ago, is now often described by those involved as one of the worst in Oscars history.

"Brokeback Mountain" had dominated awards season, securing wins at major ceremonies like the BAFTAs and Golden Globes. "Crash" co-writer Bobby Moresco admitted he had assumed "Brokeback Mountain" would win, acknowledging its groundbreaking nature. He noted that the win for "Crash," which grossed $98.4 million globally, was due to Academy voters choosing a film that resonated with them privately.

Despite criticism for its simplistic portrayal of race issues, "Crash" resonated with audiences and was supported by Academy voters who, according to strategist Lisa Taback, may have favored an underdog. Director Paul Haggis dismissed claims of homophobia influencing the vote, citing other films with gay protagonists that were nominated that year.

Even director Paul Haggis later conceded that "Crash" might not have been the year's best film artistically, though he acknowledged its profound impact on many viewers. A 2015 poll indicated that Academy members would have favored "Brokeback Mountain" if given a second chance, highlighting the enduring controversy surrounding "Crash's" victory.