Elizabeth Olsen Stars in Soul-Picking Romantic Fantasy

An appealingly old-fashioned romantic comedy with a fantasy twist, this 2025 film stars Elizabeth Olsen as a woman at the center of a celestial love triangle. The story begins with an elderly couple, Joan and Larry, whose lives are nearing their end. Larry dies suddenly but awakens in the afterlife as a younger man, Miles Teller, at the junction where souls choose their eternal destiny.

He is reborn at the age he was happiest, tasked with selecting his afterlife. The arrival of Joan, played by Olsen, presents a poignant dilemma. She must choose between spending eternity with Larry, her husband of 65 years, or Luke, her first love and husband from the Korean War era, portrayed by Callum Turner. Olsen delivers a beautiful performance in this funny, charming, and poignant film.