What did Tami Fishel think of Andy Richter's DWTS performance?

Tami Fishel was impressed by Andy Richter's DWTS performance, stating that his quickstep routine exceeded her expectations and that he "really moved" during the dance.

How did Kaitlyn Bristowe's actions impact the votes for Andy Richter?

Tami Fishel believed that Kaitlyn Bristowe ripping open Andy Richter's shirt and revealing his abs during the relay dance could have led to an "influx of phone calls, of votes and texts" for Richter.

Why was Tami Fishel surprised that Andy Richter was eliminated from DWTS?

Despite Richter's impressive performance and the potential boost in votes from Bristowe's actions, Tami Fishel expressed surprise that Richter was eliminated from the competition, saying "I can't believe I'm saying this, but I was somehow surprised that Andy went home tonight."

Home / Arts and Entertainment / DWTS Shocker: Beloved Contestant Eliminated Despite Impressive Performance

DWTS Shocker: Beloved Contestant Eliminated Despite Impressive Performance

12 Nov, 2025

•

Summary

Tami Fishel praises Andy Richter's DWTS performance
Richter's quickstep routine exceeded Fishel's expectations
Kaitlyn Bristowe's shirtless reveal boosted Richter's votes

DWTS Shocker: Beloved Contestant Eliminated Despite Impressive Performance

On November 12, 2025, former DWTS contestant Tami Fishel shared her thoughts on the latest episode of the show, which featured a surprising elimination. Fishel, who competed on the current season of DWTS, was impressed by the performance of contestant Andy Richter, who she believed had one of his best nights on the show.