Bridgerton Shocker: Benedict's Mistress Offer Sparks Outrage

Bridgerton showrunner Jess Brownell has broken her silence regarding Benedict's controversial offer to Sophie in season 4. Benedict, torn between two women, ultimately suggests Sophie, a maid, become his mistress, a decision met with viewer outrage. Brownell stated that while the offer was a significant mistake, it reflected the era's societal norms and Benedict's own unaddressed privilege. She explained that Benedict's progressive views are often performative, as he hasn't truly confronted his privileged upbringing or acted bravely. The potential consequences of such a relationship were significant, as it could lead to societal punishment and negatively impact his sisters' eligibility for marriage. Brownell also previously expressed excitement about exploring Benedict's full character arc before he settles down, noting his desire to live a large life. Actor Luke Thompson, who plays Benedict, reflected on his character's tendency to romanticize rather than engage with reality, suggesting a modern dynamic where Sophie's pragmatism complements Benedict's idealism.