Abby Elliot Discovers Surprising Connection Between Her Two Chicago-Set Shows

As of November 7th, 2025, the streaming wars continue to rage on, with each service boasting its own hit shows. For Hulu subscribers, one of the best shows to watch is "The Bear", which features actress Abby Elliot in the role of Natalie, also known as "Sugar". Elliot is now starring in a new book-to-screen adaptation, "All Her Fault", which is currently streaming on Peacock.

In a recent interview, Elliot revealed a surprising connection between the two Chicago-set shows. While filming "All Her Fault", Elliot was able to spot familiar Chicago traffic patterns in the car scenes, despite being on the other side of the world. This attention to detail in the new Peacock series has clearly impressed Elliot, who is no stranger to the city's unique landscape.

Elliot's success in "The Bear" has also made her a local celebrity in Chicago, where she now enjoys VIP treatment when dining out. The Emmy-winning actress shared that her newfound fame has been a wild experience, as she navigates the city's restaurant scene with a newfound level of recognition.

"All Her Fault" is a mystery series led by Emmy and Tony-winning actress Sarah Snook, who plays Marissa, a married woman whose child Milo goes missing. Elliot portrays Lia Irvine, the sister of Marissa's husband, Peter, played by Jake Lacy. While the family may appear to have it all together on the surface, the truth becomes increasingly twisted as the eight-episode season unfolds.

As viewers dive into "All Her Fault" on Peacock, they can expect to be captivated by the show's meticulous attention to detail and the strong performances from the cast, including Abby Elliot's standout turn as Lia.