Yankees' McMahon: A Surprise Shortstop Option?

The Yankees are preparing for significant roster decisions in 2026, initiating a notable experiment by evaluating third baseman Ryan McMahon as a potential backup shortstop. This move comes as Anthony Volpe continues his rehabilitation from left shoulder surgery, a procedure performed in October 2025 that uncovered unexpected damage.

Volpe, who underwent surgery after injuring himself on May 3, 2025, reflected on his inconsistent previous season. Despite his discomfort, he stated he felt capable of playing through the injury. The operation followed months of lingering pain in his left shoulder, contributing to his statistical decline, including a .212 batting average.

Volpe's recovery has been challenging, but he reported feeling significantly better by the start of 2026. He is currently engaged in fielding drills and hitting progressions. Meanwhile, Jose Caballero is slated to begin the season as the Yankees' starting shortstop, with the team seeking additional options like McMahon to ensure flexibility.

Despite the team's exploration of alternatives, Volpe remains determined to return to the shortstop position. If his rehabilitation progresses as planned, he is projected to be ready for action by late April or early May of 2026.