Home / Sports / Can Yankees Fit $36M Ace Cole Into Unbreakable Rotation?
Can Yankees Fit $36M Ace Cole Into Unbreakable Rotation?
24 Apr
Summary
- Gerrit Cole aims to regain elite form after Tommy John surgery.
- Yankees rotation thrives despite key pitchers' absences.
- Team faces dilemma: accommodate ace or maintain current success.
The New York Yankees are enjoying a strong start to the 2026 season, a performance made more remarkable by the absence of several key pitchers. Ace Gerrit Cole is currently recovering from Tommy John surgery, which sidelined him for the entire 2025 season. His first rehab start on April 24, 2026, showed promise, with Cole pitching 4 1/3 innings on 44 pitches, allowing one home run and striking out three batters. However, this outing was far from the Cy Young-caliber performance the Yankees will need.
In Cole's absence, and alongside Carlos Rodón's current injury status, the Yankees' starting rotation has unexpectedly emerged as one of MLB's most dominant units. This success has created a unique dilemma for the franchise: how to integrate a $36 million-a-year ace into a rotation that is currently performing at its peak. With three years and over $100 million remaining on his contract, Cole is not a trade option nor suited for a bullpen role, presenting a complex strategic challenge for the team's management.
