What was the most controversial moment in Wales vs. New Zealand rugby history?

The 1978 match is remembered for a disputed penalty call that players felt was a deliberate 'con job', leading to deep resentment.

How did the 2004 Wales vs. New Zealand game end?

Wales narrowly lost in 2004 after a clock malfunction in the final seconds cost them a chance to secure a shock victory.

Did Wales ever beat New Zealand in rugby history?

While the article focuses on near misses and heartbreaks, it implies that a victory has been elusive for extended periods, though it doesn't state they've never won.

Home / Sports / Wales' Rugby Heartbreak: Decades of Near Misses

Wales' Rugby Heartbreak: Decades of Near Misses

22 Nov, 2025

•

Summary

Wales has a long history of close rugby matches with New Zealand.
A controversial penalty in 1978 deeply affected Welsh players.
Close calls in 2004 and 1978 highlight persistent rugby heartbreak.

Wales' Rugby Heartbreak: Decades of Near Misses

Wales' rugby legacy is marked by a series of agonizing near misses against New Zealand. The 1978 encounter is particularly infamous, with players like Geoff Wheel and Windsor citing a controversial penalty as a 'con job' and the 'worst day' of their careers, a memory that lingered for decades.

Fast forward to 2004, a new-look Welsh team, bolstered by emerging talent like Gavin Henson, defied expectations. Despite an inspiring first half, New Zealand's Joe Rokocoko delivered solo brilliance. However, Wales fought back valiantly, only to be denied a historic upset by a critical misinterpretation of the stadium clock in the final moments.

This late-game misfortune, akin to the 1978 controversy, left try-scorer Tom Shanklin feeling that the pain of coming so close, rather than the initial satisfaction of a good performance, has grown over time. Yet, this era also set the stage for future success, culminating in a Grand Slam the following year.