Interim Coaches: Blessing or Curse for PSU Football?

Terry Smith, a former Penn State player with deep community ties, is a strong candidate for the head coaching position after James Franklin's dismissal. His familiarity with the program's culture and administration positions him favorably. The article cautions against the impulse to fire coaches mid-season, as this often satisfies immediate frustrations but rarely improves team performance. Data shows eight Power 4 teams making such changes are now 11-33, a significant drop from their previous 18-26 record.

The practice of making coaching changes during the season also fails to provide a significant advantage in the search for a permanent replacement. Teams like Arkansas and Oklahoma State have faced prolonged searches. The article suggests that athletic directors can discreetly identify candidates through professional networks without creating a public vacancy. This approach allows for a more thorough and less pressured decision-making process.

While interim coaches like Smith can gain significant support, history suggests their long-term success is not guaranteed. Examples like Clay Helton at USC and Rodney Terry with Texas basketball illustrate that interim success doesn't always translate to sustained achievements. Even Dabo Swinney's celebrated tenure at Clemson is questioned in today's environment, highlighting the risks associated with promoting from within after mid-season changes.