Why is there a debate between Miami and Notre Dame for the College Football Playoff?

The debate centers on their head-to-head matchup, rankings, and recent performance, with Miami holding a win but trailing in the CFP standings.

Did Miami beat Notre Dame this season?

Yes, Miami defeated Notre Dame 27-24 in their season opener.

What are Miami's strengths in their College Football Playoff case?

Miami has shown significant offensive improvement, leading in key stats since their SMU loss and demonstrating a complete team effort.

Home / Sports / Miami vs. Notre Dame: Playoff Debate Heats Up

Miami vs. Notre Dame: Playoff Debate Heats Up

4 Dec

•

Summary

Miami beat Notre Dame head-to-head early this season.
Miami leads Power 4 teams in key offensive stats since SMU loss.
Despite head-to-head win, Miami ranks behind Notre Dame.

Miami vs. Notre Dame: Playoff Debate Heats Up

The College Football Playoff picture is heating up, with significant debate surrounding the rankings of Miami and Notre Dame. Despite Miami securing a season-opening 27-24 victory over the Irish, the Hurricanes currently trail Notre Dame in both the CFP and AP polls. This discrepancy is particularly puzzling given Miami's recent strong performance.

Since their conference road loss to SMU, Miami has shown marked improvement. They lead all Power 4 teams in completion percentage, sack differential, touchdown passes, and lowest 3-and-out punt percentage. Advanced metrics also place them top five in yards per play difference, points per drive difference, and scoring margin, suggesting they are playing their best football.

However, pollsters and the CFP committee appear to be weighing factors beyond the head-to-head result. Arguments regarding Notre Dame's overall power ratings and strength of schedule are being considered, even as Miami demonstrates a complete team effort with top-tier offensive and defensive efficiency.