Tilak Varma favored over Pant for India's XI

As India prepares for the ODI series against South Africa, a debate has emerged over Tilak Varma and Rishabh Pant for the playing XI. Former selector Saba Karim has strongly advocated for Varma to occupy the crucial No. 4 position, seeing him as the ideal replacement for the injured Shreyas Iyer. Karim's reasoning centers on maintaining a solid top order and avoiding a scenario where picking Pant necessitates playing with fewer specialist bowlers.

Karim's analysis suggests that if Varma is selected at No. 4, KL Rahul would likely continue as the wicketkeeper, leaving no immediate place for Pant unless the team opts for a more top-heavy batting order with five specialist bowlers. This tactical consideration highlights the delicate balance India aims to strike in its quest for a strong performance after their Test series loss.

Meanwhile, Indian captain KL Rahul offered a nuanced perspective, confirming that Pant possesses the skill to feature as a specialist batter. However, he deferred the final decision on the playing XI until match day. Rahul also reiterated his own batting position at No. 6, underscoring the team's strategic planning amidst player absences.