What team did Dustin May play for before the Cardinals?

Dustin May played for the Boston Red Sox and Los Angeles Dodgers in the 2025 season before signing with the St. Louis Cardinals.

Why is Dustin May's contract with the Cardinals considered a gamble?

Dustin May has a history of significant injuries, including two major elbow surgeries, which has limited his availability and consistency throughout his career.

How will Dustin May impact the St. Louis Cardinals' rotation?

May is expected to be a top starter for the Cardinals, potentially leading a relatively inexperienced rotation that lost ace Sonny Gray.

Home / Sports / Dustin May Joins Cardinals: A Risky Rotation Gamble

Dustin May Joins Cardinals: A Risky Rotation Gamble

14 Dec, 2025

•

Summary

Cardinals sign pitcher Dustin May to a one-year contract.
May joins St. Louis after a turbulent season with Dodgers and Red Sox.
Health and consistency remain key concerns for May's potential.

Dustin May Joins Cardinals: A Risky Rotation Gamble

The St. Louis Cardinals have secured a one-year contract with right-handed pitcher Dustin May, a move aimed at strengthening their starting rotation. May, who was acquired by the Red Sox from the Dodgers last season, struggled to find his footing in Boston, posting a 5.40 ERA in limited appearances.

May's previous year was marred by Tommy John surgery revision and subsequent struggles with both the Dodgers and Red Sox. His career has been significantly impacted by various injuries, limiting his game appearances since his debut. Staying healthy and harnessing his pitching arsenal will be crucial for his success.

Ranked on The Athletic's free agent list, May's deal is notably shorter than projected. He will now lead a Cardinals rotation alongside returning pitchers, as the team navigates its rebuilding phase and seeks to solidify its pitching staff for the upcoming season.