Richardson Staying Put? Colts QB's Trade Options Vanish

Anthony Richardson Sr.'s tenure with the Indianapolis Colts has been fraught with challenges, leading to his trade request in February 2026. Despite being granted permission to explore new destinations, no trade has materialized as of May 6, 2026. Daniel Jones is now the undisputed starter, having signed a significant extension, leaving Richardson's future in Indianapolis uncertain.

The trade market for Richardson has effectively vanished, with teams like the Green Bay Packers, Arizona Cardinals, San Francisco 49ers, and Los Angeles Rams having full quarterback rooms. This situation points towards Richardson remaining with the Colts to complete his rookie contract, especially after the team declined his fifth-year option. While not the desired outcome, Richardson has an opportunity to compete for the backup QB role in 2026 against Riley Leonard, provided he significantly improves his fundamentals and understanding of NFL defenses.

This scenario presents a difficult path for both Richardson and the Colts. Indianapolis sought to gain value from their high draft investment, while Richardson and his agent believe a change of scenery is crucial for his career. However, with no immediate trade prospects, Richardson faces the challenge of proving himself as a capable backup to Daniel Jones, whose injury history could potentially open the door for Richardson to see playing time.

Richardson's opportunity to secure the backup position hinges on his ability to overcome past inconsistencies and demonstrate growth. The upcoming rookie minicamp will offer an early glimpse into his progress. As of May 6, 2026, his path forward with the Colts is one of significant challenge and requires substantial improvement to alter his current trajectory.