Who do college baseball coaches consider the greatest players of all time?

Coaches cited numerous players, including Pat Burrell, Buster Posey, Todd Walker, Dylan Crews, Ben McDonald, Paul Skenes, Colin Poche, Stephen Strasburg, and Gerrit Cole, among others.

What qualities do coaches look for when evaluating college baseball prospects?

Coaches discussed prioritizing bat-to-ball skills, contact consistency, strike zone discipline, and command for pitchers, while also valuing the 'eye test' over pure statistics.

Which teams are expected to surprise in the 2026 college baseball season?

While specific teams were mentioned, the article focuses more on individual player achievements and coaching insights rather than a definitive list of surprise teams for 2026.

Home / Sports / Coaches Reveal All-Time College Baseball Legends

Coaches Reveal All-Time College Baseball Legends

10 Feb

•

Summary

Coaches named their greatest college baseball players.
Discussions included top position players and pitchers.
Player evaluations focus on specific skills and impact.

Coaches Reveal All-Time College Baseball Legends

The 2026 college baseball season is set to begin, prompting coaches to share their perspectives on the sport's history and future. In a recent forum, coaches identified the best position players and pitchers they have ever seen compete at the college level. Discussions also touched upon emerging teams expected to surprise in the upcoming season and the key statistics coaches value when assessing prospects.

Notable players mentioned include J.D. Arteaga's "unbelievable" freshman Pat Burrell in 1996 and Buster Posey in 2008. Mike Bianco cited Todd Walker's consistent .400 batting average over three years. Dylan Crews was highlighted by Dan Fitzgerald for his high-level performance and clutch abilities.

Pitching standouts also featured prominently, with coaches like Mike Bianco recalling Ben McDonald and Paul Skenes. Dan Fitzgerald praised Colin Poche for his exceptional command, while Scott Forbes mentioned Stephen Strasburg and Gerrit Cole for their dominance. The conversations offered a comprehensive look at college baseball's elite.