Home / Sports / Reds Face Catcher Crisis in 2026 Offseason
Reds Face Catcher Crisis in 2026 Offseason
30 Sep
Summary
- Stephenson likely seeking multi-year deal around $8-12 million annually.
- Carson Kelly projected for a two-year deal at $6-8 million AAV.
- Prospect Alfredo Duno is expected to be the future catcher for Reds.
Heading into the 2026 offseason, the Cincinnati Reds are confronted with considerable uncertainty at the catcher position. The potential departure of Tyler Stephenson, who is expected to seek a multi-year contract valued between $8-12 million per year in free agency, leaves a void. While Stephenson could return, the Reds might be outbid.
Carson Kelly is another prominent free-agent catcher. Projections suggest he could sign a two-year deal averaging $6-8 million annually, potentially making him a more economical choice than Stephenson. The Reds' current catching depth includes Jose Trevino, Will Banfield, and PJ Higgins, with Alfredo Duno positioned as the long-term future at the position.
Given Duno's projected arrival in approximately two years, the Reds may opt for a short-term veteran signing. Jonah Heim is mentioned as a possibility for a one- or two-year mentorship role. Catcher is identified as the team's most critical offseason need.
